Avoid These 4 Small Business Saturday Shop Small Retail Mistakes
Subscribe to our newsletter
Small Business Saturday 2026 is on Saturday, November 28, 2026, the Saturday after Thanksgiving.
The independents who win this day don't win it with 10% off.
They win it by giving neighbors a reason to walk in, someone who greets them, and a reason to come back in January.
While the day prior - Black Friday - is big chains’ day, Saturday is the day for independents to amp up their volume.
It is your chance to gain exposure to your neighborhood shoppers. For that reason, you want to make the day memorable for them.
What Are the Biggest Small Business Saturday Mistakes?
The four biggest Small Business Saturday mistakes are leading with a discount, assuming shoppers will just show up, not prepping your crew, and making the day only about the sale.
Mistake #1: Leading With a Discount
Making the day memorable doesn’t revolve around a discount.
Why?
A discount does nothing to build your reputation as a retailer, and it doesn’t give your shoppers a reason to go out of their way to visit you.
A discount is not memorable.
A discount is not remarkable.
What is remarkable?
For one thing, you need to make your street a shopping destination. The power that can drive your Small Business event is the word community.
Now is the time to join forces with other local businesses, so you can generate more awareness of this huge shop small day and your events happening around it.
And those businesses don’t all have to be retailers on your street…
Why not contact your local hardware or lumber center and a local design firm and have them build your shopping community a Selfie station. Your Selfie station could be a booth covered with awesome graphics that make passersby have to stop and take a photo to share on their social media sites.
A bonus would be getting someone to donate the use of a big monitor that shows all the Instagram and TikTok posts from your Selfie station in real time.
Mistake #2: Assuming Shoppers Will Just Show Up
Nothing could be further from the truth.
Last year, a CNBC|SurveyMonkey poll found only 23% of Americans planned to shop Small Business Saturday. What kept the rest away? Not knowing which local shops were taking part, and higher sticker prices.
The first one is on you to fix with promotion.
The second one isn't a pricing problem. It's a selling problem.
If you want the day to be a success, you need to promote it a couple of weeks before through your email list and a press release to your local media.
Then release these four social media updates (remember these should be written and scheduled ahead of time):
· Tomorrow is Small Business Saturday and we’ll be open 10-8pm. We would love to have you visit to show the power of shopping local.
· Friends don’t let friends go to the mall today, Small Business Saturday. We’re open until 8pm!
· What did you buy this morning at our great local retailers on Small Business Saturday?
· There’s still time to visit during Small Business Saturday. We’re here until 8pm.
Mistake #3: Not Prepping Your Crew
Tell your crew why this is an important day. It's a chance to gain new shoppers for the coming holiday and the coming year.
That means you have to step up your service levels on that busy Saturday to give customers something to rave about. Go beyond just saying, “Hi” and “What can we help you with?”
Go beyond events
A lot of merchants hold special events. Octavia Books in New Orleans, plans to have several well-known local authors come into the store and read their favorite children and adult books. Last year they had over 100 people attend.
That builds on itself so each year customers look forward to coming back.
That is the magic of customer loyalty.
Encourage everyone who visits your store that day to leave you a Google review or tag you on Instagram. In the 2026 American Express Shop Small study, 45% of shoppers said ratings and reviews influence which small business they choose.
And when customers checkout, encourage them to sign up for your email list and to follow you on social media.
This is a golden day when millions of dollars will be spread across media promoting shopping local. And while you can proudly say that you don’t take American Express – which I think is not wise as I’ve said here before – the reality is AMEX has made this day.
You can hitch your business to this branded shopping day and raise awareness of your local business for no money.
Mistake #4: Making It Only About the Sale
If you’ve read any of my materials about Millennials, you know they expect to see businesses doing more to make their community vibrant.
Join with your other retailers to pledge that x amount of purchases will be given to charity.
If you can’t get anyone in your town to join you, just do it on your own. If you are a sporting goods store, could you donate equipment to your local high school?
If you’re a bookstore, choose a local charity that provides books for retirement homes or Head Start programs.
If you’re a shoe store, you can give shoes to a local homeless program.
If you’re an outerwear store you can ask customers to join you to donate a coat to keep someone else warm, One Warm Coat is a great resource for you.
You get the idea - the sky’s the limit.
This day is your chance to go beyond just shop local. And checkout SBS's free marketing tools for retailers here.
Download How To Talk To The Media About Small Business Saturday
What's New for Small Business Saturday 2026?
Shoppers reported spending an estimated $18 billion on Small Business Saturday 2025. That's down from about $22 billion the year before, according to American Express's own surveys.
Intent is up, though. In Amex's 2026 Shop Small Impact Study, 88% of shoppers said they're likely to shop small this holiday season, the highest since Amex started tracking.
The gap between those two numbers is your sales floor.
1. Find out if AI can find you.
35% of shoppers plan to use AI to find a small business this season, and 45% of Gen Z and millennials do. Ask ChatGPT, Gemini, or Claude, "Where should I buy a gift in [your town]?"
If you're not in the answer, update your Google Business Profile with your holiday hours, new photos, and what you sell, in the words a shopper would use.
2. Have AI grade your flyer before you print it.
Give your newsletter, event flyer, or holiday help-wanted ad to a free AI tool. Ask it to grade it the way an excellent marketer would.
Expect a C or a D. Then ask it to fix it.
3. Sell the memorable gift, not the markdown.
72% of shoppers say they shop small to find memorable gifts. Your crew should be asking who the gift is for and bringing out options - not pointing to the sale table.
That's a skill you can train, and it's what SalesRX+ was built to teach.
4. Turn your street into a passport.
Shoppers collect a stamp at each participating store and turn a full card in for a prize. Klem's, a family hardware store in Spencer, Massachusetts, goes further with pop-ups featuring local breweries, a winery, and a gourmet doughnut shop.
A Novel Idea on Passyunk, a Philadelphia bookstore, runs a "Blind Date with a Book" game. People talk about that. Nobody talks about 10% off.
5. Send the thank-you the week after.
Email everyone who visited the following week. 65% of shoppers pick a small business on a friend's or family member's recommendation, so write it to be forwarded.
That's how a Saturday shopper becomes a January customer.
In Sum
On this day, you have an opportunity to show the power of community. That’s really the missing piece to this Saturday.
It isn’t just another day to give 10% off.
It isn’t about you getting more sales.
It is about you showing the power of a vibrant merchant community.
That you’re not alone.
That your customers aren’t alone; they have allies like you doing good work too.
Do this and you’ll avoid the mistake of approaching this day with your hand out.