Can You Know If Your Marketing ROI Is Working For Your Retail Business?
By Bob Phibbs
Most every retail business owner is frustrated with their marketing costs because they don’t know how to calculate their return on investment (ROI) for the amount of money spent.
That’s usually because they have to justify their budget to a partner or CFO.
This past week, a client told me a “business expert” said she felt branding and marketing had virtually no relevance to small, family-owned businesses since its expense and demand on resources is beyond the ability of most family-owned businesses to execute.
The woman said a small business shouldn't bother wrapping a vehicle because it's not going to change anyone's behavior or educate them about the business. She also said that if two pool companies show up to bid a job, no matter what their branding look like, the one that charges less is going to get it.
My client wanted to know what I thought...
I said well first, price doesn’t make something a good value.
Look at the largest recall in auto history today because automakers wanted to save a couple bucks on their airbags. Takata came in with the lowest price and got the job. With disastrous results.
Everyone’s had an experience with a low-ball price and the disappointed story to go with it.
If it were all about price, no one would be in business.
Second, you’re never going to know the effect marketing has as a cause and effect for influencing customers’ behavior.
As Daniel Kehrer says, “Calculating ROI oblivious to the business objectives context is like trying to keep a game score without even knowing what sport you’re playing – a fruitless endeavor to be sure.”
So in order to try to justify costs, you need to keep in mind the three steps in your buyer’s journey to your product or service..to you.
In the first step, Awareness, they realize they have a problem. In step two, Consideration, they define their problem and seek ways to solve it, and finally, in the Decision stage, they choose a solution.
Here’s an example for a window covering store customer:
I’m tired of the sun waking me up every morning because I work late.
Aha, I have crappy window coverings. What are my options at keeping out the sun in the morning? The drapes take longer to get, but the shutters won’t be as room darkening.
I’m going to buy the drapes, but from who? I’ll do a Google search for top results in my area. “Oh, what was that ad I saw? What’s that company with the van down the street?” I’ll see what their website looks like, and ask my friends for their recommendations.
Most marketers only look at influencing an incremental sale - the Decision stage. That’s why so many put a coupon into every ad, for proof their ad brought the customer in.
Sorry, trying to attribute every purchase to a post, a coupon, or campaign is just not that easy.
If you consider all the reasons customers come into your store, if you market to their awareness reasons and consideration reasons, and not just to their decision reasons, you will have several messages that build up your brand and, at the same time, eliminate your need for discounting which will lead to higher profits.
Which of course, is what anyone is searching for when they start promoting themselves...higher profits.
So if you were the window coverings store and you wanted to increase your awareness of your brand, one message on your wrapped truck could be, “Put a stop to the sun in your eyes!" Your consideration ad could read, “Shutters, curtains, or blinds? We have all the options.”
It will always be hard to measure how your ad or billboard grabbed potential shoppers’ awareness or how many new customers you gained. But you still have to create a brand shoppers are aware of and deliver service beyond compare. The bonus of word-of-mouth will help bolster your advertising efforts as well.
That's not to say you shouldn't be looking for cause and effect with your marketing. The HBR noted in this article that a company "found that organic visits to the website and display advertisement click-through all increased disproportionally in a region when consumers there were also exposed to TV ads. This experiment motivated the firm to start better coordinating their marketing campaigns across media channels."
You need an arsenal of tools to build awareness for customers considering changing their brand, or acquiring a new product. Some are looking for information - awareness - and some have information - consideration.
You need a variety of means to reach them in the consideration phase so they understand what solutions you have that make you standout from the rest and when they are in the decision stage to choose you in the first place, or to come back and shop more often, or to refer you to a friend.
Van wraps, billboards, blogs, and those type of things attract people who have a need for what you sell.
Responsive websites, paid search, SEO, and other digital tools are excellent at attracting shoppers to consider you as their answer.
Well-done videos, case studies, pictures of your product in actual customer’s homes and testimonials all help you close the sale when the customer is in the decision stage.
And of course I would be remiss if I didn’t say retail sales training is so important because the final discovery phase is usually in your physical store.
It always shocks me when I see a retailer having a going-out-of-business sale.
Where is the first place they advertise?
In the newspaper. Talk to most any newspaper representative and they’ll tell you the company never ran an ad before claiming there was no return on investment.
There is an ROI, just make sure to not expect it to be as clear as number-of-coupons redeemed, and make sure you spend more time in the awareness and consideration stages of your buyer’s journey.
Promoting your business, like retail sales training of your crew, is an investment. It is not an expense.
If you want to succeed, the focus has to be on how effective your message is to each of the three distinct segments of a shopper’s buying journey, and not on whether the $200 ad you ran once in the freebie weekly got enough coupon-clippers to justify the cost.
Get our weekly newsletter updates. Read our mailing consent T&Cs here
The 5 Shifts Brick-and-Mortar Retailers Are Making to Generate Up to 20% Higher Profits Every Month
Are you a hungry brick-and-mortar store owner who’s ready for a fresh, people-obsessed strategy? This training is for you if you want to grow your business using a powerful customer experience formula proven to make your cash register chirp.