The Jobs Problem In Retail Isn’t What You Think
Much was written about people quitting and the Great Resignation. People often quit and find the grass isn't always greener.
But the jobs problem in retail isn't what others are telling you.
I was in Manhattan recently shopping and enjoying a trip to Gabriel’s, the high-end bistro on Central Park South.
Walking back to the hotel, I decided to check out Abercrombie’s reinvention. After all, I’d just read that Carey Krug, SVP of marketing at Abercrombie, said, “TikTok is bananas for us right now. The new customers that we are reaching — it’s far exceeding our benchmarks. It’s far exceeding TikTok’s benchmarks.”
This store and catalog once featured what some considered soft porn – shirtless young men wearing Zinka nose coat sunscreen to give the SoCal vibe. That is until the CEO was forced out, and the models put their shirts back on.
I walked into the store with a friend. Two young women were to my right, leaning on a banister. They obviously worked there. We went toward the other side of the store.
There was a long-sleeved graphic t-shirt that was interesting. I thumbed through the neatly stacked merch but couldn’t find a large. My friend interrupted one of the young women who came over to look – in the same pile I had. She confirmed they did not have a large, and she’d go look in the back.
Meanwhile, I’d just looked at the table to the left, where piles of the same shirt were on a lower shelf. I found the right size and handed it to my friend. The sales clerk seemed surprised.
She went back to the banister, and we went to be rung up in the back, where two other employees were talking and laughing. After a few moments, my friend asked, “Is this where you pay?” The one guy stopped talking, I think he was the manager, ran behind the register, and tried to get my friend to sign up for their points or credit card or something to get $10 off.
The whole experience was as if we had been alone in the store with AI robots doing the minimum.
The energy the store would have had from engaged employees was missing - if anything, their casualness of not engaging took energy from the store.
In software, they have a term - MVP - a minimum viable product. It is where a new product is introduced with basic features to see how the market reacts. Think Apple OS 15. They get it out as quickly as possible, knowing they will return with OS 15.1 that could fix or add on things missed in the original launch.
The people problem in retail
In retail, we seem to have the MVP or minimum value person. It is when an associate does the minimum viable engagement. They are trained on a few basics- they ask/you get, they pay/you offer loyalty.
And the Great Resignation makes it all so much worse.
How is it that retailers as a whole have so many holes in the schedule while some stores have plenty of people – but associates show no training, hustle, or drive?
The hubris of considering associates replaceable cogs has to end.
And how does that affect those brands' ability to become employers of choice?
A recent article in Inc. on why workers were really quitting, stated that the reason so many people are quitting has everything to do with their relationship with their bosses. A Udemy study found that nearly half of the employees surveyed had quit because of a bad manager, and almost two-thirds believed their manager lacked proper managerial training.
Five people working in a store where they are only talking to each other directly correlates to their training but, more importantly, the training their managers haven't had.
Unless people are trained in the basics of leadership – setting direction, checking in regularly, observing, correcting, rewarding, and holding people accountable, situations as I experienced, occur throughout the retail world.
These are skills the average person has not developed and why they won’t unless you provide the means for them.
Why capable managers don’t lead
I recently had a request for training for managers. The prospective client said, “I have managers who feel bad correcting people, so they don’t do it.”
That’s the crux of the matter, isn’t it?
When the people most charged with holding people accountable either can’t or won’t do that, the whole system fails.
And why don’t retail managers hold associates accountable?
- They Haven't set Clear Expectations
- There are no Consequences
- They Want to be Liked
- They Have no Training
And let’s face it, the more associates or managers text, the less they look to engage with strangers.
Doubt me? Try to catch someone’s face at your local coffeehouse.
It leads us to think many people are shy.
Shyness is fine, but shyness can stop you from doing all the things you want in life that you’d like to – The Smiths
But really, it seems they aren’t as shy as much as they might experience anxiety about interacting with others. They might be afraid of being judged negatively in some way due to poor experiences in the past or even being bullied on social media.
The thing is, oftentimes at the register, after the sale is made, they enjoy conversation, and with the pressure of “having to sell something” off their shoulders, they feel they can relax.
But that isn’t the job.
That’s a bartender.
What is a retail associate’s job in a store?
A retail associate’s job is to meet the customer in the aisles because that is where the connections are made.
That’s where the spark of conversation leads to a first date.
Where the encounter with an actor they didn’t expect occurs.
Where they find someone who shares the same interest.
Where time stops and energy is released.
And yes, where the big sales happen – by selling.
Oh, there’s that word again selling.
I’ll bet many of you reading this got a twinge of anxiety just from reading the word selling.
Now imagine an untrained salesperson.
The truth about selling
And yet, nothing you are wearing, sitting on, touching, or viewing happens without someone somewhere selling it.
It’s time we make friends with selling and by selling your merchandise.
That’s because, unless you’re Apple, 70% of what you stock is carried by many of your competitors - both online and off.
All you have is the ability to convince and convert those lookers who come to your store into buyers.
Unless of course, you want to be a showroom for the brands you carry so your shoppers can return to their site and give that brand their money and not you, you have to move past the MVP associate.
But maybe you’re living in a different reality. One where you believe customers who supported you this past year will do so next year...
Your increases of 20, 30, and even 40% this year will continue unabated.
A different world where customers no longer need to be sold anything; they just buy.
Only water sells itself.
And unless enough sales are made, you do not have a business, you have a tax deduction.
But the reality is things are changing…
Did you hear last week that Facebook has now become Menta? Do you think they're going to compete with retail? Yeah. They want to eat retail.
They want to eat YouTube. They want to eat Google. They want to eat everybody.
Just like Amazon.
There are two kinds of retailers - the ones who play not to lose (fear, defense, price cuts) and the ones who play to win (bold, winning customer experience, strong sales culture)
If you want to play to win instead of losing...
Here's what your retail operation needs to do:
- Stop confusing bodies with employees
Here’s what your store needs to do:
- Start to train managers on how to lead
- Hold managers accountable for doing more than the minimum
Here's what your people need to do:
- Initiate conversation
- Develop a bigger vision of help
- Be trained how the soft skills of engagement
The world is changing faster than you realize; your head's in your store, your head's in your numbers, but your head's not in the real world. Otherwise, you would see what I see.
There are things you can do now where your success and your competitor's success are measured in days and weeks.
It's not going to be measured in months and years.
And the time to act is now.
Four retail brands that went bust
Sears thought they could do no wrong
Back in 1969, they were the world’s largest retailer. They purchased Dean Witter and Coldwell Banker in the mid-eighties and created the Discover Card. In 1990 Sears and the relative upstart Walmart each sold about $32 billion. As the Economist writes: “Sears was not alone in occupying the uncomfortable ground between discounters whose prices it could not match and high-end retailers whose stores and products outshone its own.”
JC Penney thought they had time
Back in 2006, they sold about $20 billion. They moved from priding themselves on employee training and private labels to Ron Johnson’s disastrous unproven strategy of everyday low prices with new brands and formats launched with a lot of PR but little value. Confused loyal customers fled the scene, never to return.
What caused Circuit City to fail?
In the 90s, they sold about $12 billion, a one-stop spot for appliances and electronics. As sales rose, the fundamentals of location were thrown aside to expand into more dicey locations. Their new CEO didn’t want to be in the appliance business and discontinued that department which made up 30% of sales. They fired their best salespeople to save money and replaced them with cheaper untrained hourly employees.
Why did Radio Shack close stores?
In the 80s, they were the 100-year-old company with one of the first affordable home computers. They kept their innovative cell phones locked up in cases to sell only if someone with very deep pockets asked for them. By the mid-2000s, they moved cell phones to the front, but by then, the cell providers were opening their own stores. All their training went to techniques to qualify customers for a new cell phone activation.
Here's what they were thinking:
- We have enough time
- Customers will be loyal to us
- Employees are disposable.
Here's what they were doing:
- Looking at their employees as their best asset
- Looking at training their employees as an investment, not a cost
- Looking the other way at how engagement was disappearing on their sales floor.
Here's what they were not doing:
- Investing in their people
- Minding their store
- Leading their people
Don't make that same mistake.
The difference between an untrained crew and a branded experience is between a jigsaw full of pieces and the final puzzle that is whole.
If you’d like help, you should check out my online retail sales training platform SalesRX.com.