Home » Blog » Blog » Archives for January 2009
Bob Phibbs' Retail Sales Blog

Archive for January, 2009

Retail Sales Tumbled in December – End of the World!

The Wall Street Journal today has an article so full of hysteria, no wonder the market is contracting. Excluding autos and gas, sales dipped a bit over 1%. From the first few paragraphs, you’d think it was off by 20%. Imagine if your kid came home with a report card of 98.7% – would the sky be falling then?

Shri Sundaram was right when they commented on the article, “WSJ Crew: Give the readers something new. We all know we are in a recession. We all know that consumer spending has slowed considerably. And, we all know retail sales sucked this past holiday season. Why on earth are you hammering that point over and over!!!??? Give something new. Tell the readers how the economy is shaping up over the next 12-24 months. What’s the look of the boom that will follow the doom-n-gloom… Get over it.”

Indeed – get over the hysteria.

Lee Scott of Wal-Mart, Microsoft Robot and New Product at NRF

Wal-Mart CEO Lee Scott

CEO Lee Scott

OK so everyone covered Lee Scott, CEO of Wal-Mart’s comments yesterday morning at the National Retail Federation’s BIG show in NYC.

Well, maybe not everyone but Reuters and AP did a piece each which were picked up.  Here’s my take and then as promised more about new products.  

There is a mindset among big boxes that the party is over. The credit was cheap so they could finance inventory, the developers could build more and more stores so these retailers could show good comp sales (growth), the consumers could buy it all because they too had easy access to credit. Even though as retailers opened all those big stores, each one ramped up slower with much less results than in the past and Wall Street looked the other way. 

Those times are gone.

That said, Mr. Scott shared with us that Wal-Mart had a 25% increase last week in plasma TV sales in the US.  Hardly the scrimp and save picture being fed to us on the news shows.

At NRF it became clear that retail is overbuilt; that the end of the “credit party” probably means 20% of malls and retailers will fail in 2009/10.  No one wanted to speculate but there certainly wasn’t optimism in the sessions.  Maybe that’s because NRF focuses primarily on the big boxes, not the smaller retailers.

Too bad because smaller retailers can operate better than the big box tankers in such a storm because they are inherently more like a speedboat. They can manuveur around the inevitable “going out of business” sales that will be a hallmark of 2009 as poorly contributing stores fold – even whole chains. These operators can see opportunity instead of doom & gloom. They aren’t thinking they can only grow by opening in Asia, Russia or India – they want to thrive only in their local community.

Also the small to medium sized retailer doesn’t have to worry as much about coverage of the store by employees since they do not have as big of a store. Smaller stores can maintain a good ratio of employees per square foot to customers which, with proper sales training like mine, can increase sales.  Not so with the big boxes which will frustrate their customers even more.

img_0177I’ll talk much more about the economists that were in abundance at NRF next time.  Right now I want to talk about Microsoft Tag technology.  

What caught my attention was the robot Microsoft had on hand.  While I soon found out the robot had nothing to do with the product, it was a great crowd generator.

The actual program is a tag that is read by a handheld device like your Iphone (App store Microsoft Tag) or Blackberry (download for products running Windows at http://gettag.mobi.)  

When you take a picture, it opens your browser to a planned web page, or custom url or dials a phone number to give further information. (The tag I built on their site barcodeat right.)

I don’t believe customers would use this unless someone was with them at this point, especially since you have to download the app but it could be an easy way to show the product in-home or different options or actual customers using your product with clickable ratings.

You can go to the Microsoft Beta tag website  and create your own tag to see how it would work. 

At first it seems you would get this information from a salesperson but what if you were so slammed with customers, they couldn’t get to the customer waiting? Employees could use this as part of their greeting, explaining how all your best products have this and they could get further information easily until the salesperson returns.

What if an author put a scannable tag to information in their books as a way to interact with the reader in a new way? Or you could scan to a joinup page while you waited in a checkout line that would link to your rewards card signup. The possibilities are ripe for the creative because it is easy for the consumer.

Economic surveys presented at NRF said people had money to buy, they just didn’t want to right now. Who knows when that will change, but it will.  What will not change is for customers to become more patient or have more time to shop.  Tagging in the store, much like online makes sense.

Microsoft might just have something here.

Next up? Economics and lots of statistics for you to chew over.

New Products At National Retail Federation Big Show

I’ve been in NYC since Saturday at the National Retail Federation’s BIG show at the Javits Center.  I’ll be posting my thoughts over the next few days between speeches.  One of the most talked about areas was the Sonic Bar Experience.  It was a pavilion featuring several new technologies and how they might be used in the music store of the future.

One of the most interesting was Joe Engalan from VECTORform who took the time to explain how his company took last year’s hit product, the large format, multiple image Microsoft computer table and wrote a new interface for a music store.

Joe Engalan, Head of Development for VECTORform

Joe Engalan, Head of Development for VECTORform

They also hooked up a wall unit to show the dozens of onlookers. With a “gee whiz” type of attraction, Joe showed how someone could come into the music store and lay down a card that had their personal information (probably evolving to their cell phone.)  The computer would read it instantly and read their personal music like their Ipod playlist, maybe make suggestions. OK, so what Joe, the Genius playlist in Ipod already does that.  

True enough but it also could let you know which of your artists were coming to town and get tix for you, it could show you their new videos and more.

You could also mix your own dj mix using the cool touch interface (which is available now as a free download to your Iphone from the App store – search “Surface DJ”).  If you liked what you created, you could email it to yourself. Or drag it to your address book on the table to the right and email it, or the tix, or the song, to your friends.

img_0172 As we talked further, it seemed this would be much better at the  premium  product level where someone could work with the customer and use the table  to interact and guide the customer.  

 Joe smiled and told me about a BMW  dealer in  Germany  using it to show  customers exactly how they could  customize their BMW.  For the dealer,  there are cards with actual samples of  every leather.  Once the  customer  finds the exact shade they want, they  place  the card on the table, it  reads  and stores it. They can do this down to the minutest detail.

 Sure it can generate pictures at various angles but it captures all of the  information, stores  it, can email it and issue another card the customer can  simply take with them to  order online, call or email.  All that time is not wasted and the employee  who helped them gets the credit – brilliant! 

Are you going to see this in a year or two? Definately not in the mass markets but as retailers are looking to differentiate themselves, make shopping fun and technology increases accuracy and choice, you’ll see it in premium brands.

Imagine if you were able to bring in a photo and such a system could read the photo, add it to the table and you could choose your flooring in real time from actual samples in store.  Or do over your kitchen cabinets. Or add your Hunter Douglas window fashions.  Anywhere thousands of dollars are being spent for something customers traditionally have to take on trust should be looking at this now to brainstorm what such technology could do for them!

In coming days I’ll update you also on KeyRingThing, the Microsoft Commerce Server robot, Creative Communications direct mail kiosk and even CEO Lee Scott’s revelation that just last week Wal-Mart had a 25% increase in a very premium product.  Stay tuned!

December Retail Sales Not As Bad As Feared

Remember the story a week ago about how trips to the mall were off up to 30% portending huge declines in holiday retail sales? Much like the price of oil was supposed to be $5 a gallon by now? The Wall Street Journal has a great chart listing December year-over-year sales for the big retailers right here.  And guess what?  It wasn’t as bad as feared.

Sales at Aeropostale, the low-priced casual apparel store, were up 12 percent. Specialty teenage retailer Hot Topic  had a 4.3 percent sales increase. Sales at Children’s Place and Ross Stores were flat.  Even my perenial whipping post Macy’s only showed a 4% decline.

Of course Neiman Marcus and Saks were way off. Not, I think because of their price points but because long ago they too thought they could stock really expensive items that anyone could tell were worth it.  Have you gone into one of these stores lately?  

I was at Saks across from Rockefeller Center in December.  I was dressed casually but not a slob. After a long, cramped ride in an old elevator I arrived at men’s suits.

There I found three impeccably dressed gentlemen standing at the front of the floor talking about low sales. They took one look at me and continued talking.

Sure they looked the part, but if they could be that cavalier about airing their feelings, how much motivation do you think they had to sell the merch?

We’re seeing some stabilizing in retail but it is sure to be rocky the next several months.  Don’t use the word recession to limit your abilities or make excuses.  

Plan for the recovery today by hiring and training the best, no matter how they dress.

Is This The Time To Start A Retail Business?

This has to be one of the most asked questions on various blogs, TV shows, and newspapers.  Conventional wisdom is, “Heck NO!”  I say it could be, just examine your motives.  Let’s look at similar questions first.

“Is this a good time to get married?”  Look at your motives.  If it is because you don’t want to be alone, probably not.  But that won’t change with time, plenty of people are still getting married.  

“Is this a good time to have a kid?”  Look at your motives.  If it is because you feel you should because everyone else is, then you probably shouldn’t.  But again, that is not a function of current events, the answer is found by looking inside.

Now to the original question, “Is now a good time to start a retail business?” If it is because you want “something to do,”  if it is because you like to buy things, if it is because you’ve always wanted to be the boss, then you should NOT open a retail business.

If however you have great product knowledge, know exactly what break-even is, know how you will finance it in a soft economy, how you will market to your community, if you won’t sit back and “hope” people walk in the door but bring them in, if you’ll have a web presence from the start and most importantly know how to sell – this could be a good time. 

A lot of weak players will fall out of the retail market this year. This could just be opportunity knocking for the right person who has their eyes wide open, their reasons and motives well thought out and a great location.

Sign upSign up to get monthly tips and tricks delivered to your inbox direct from The Retail Doctor®, Bob Phibbs.